Earlier this month, the S&P 500 was notching fresh record highs. Since then, rising oil prices and 10-year Treasury yields at their highest levels since 2002 have brought back volatility, with the index slipping nearly 2% in the week ending October 16. On top of that, now that midterm elections are less than two weeks away, the headlines feel louder than usual. Recently we have written about stock market performance during midterm elections, and today’s weekly market commentary is another reminder on what history tells us about markets around midterm elections.

The author opens the piece by explaining, “investor concern about the midterms is already influencing investor behavior. According to recent Nationwide Retirement Institute research, 75% of investors believe the election could affect their long-term financial plan. Notably, 2 in 5 investors have already made changes to their retirement savings or investment portfolio in anticipation of the election outcome.” – NFM-25818AO (10/26)

S&P 500® Index returns one year after midterm elections since 1946

However, the enclosed graph goes on to show how the S&P 500 has performed over the 12 months following each U.S. midterm election from 1946 through 2022. Each blue bar represents the return following one election, with election years along the bottom and percentage returns on the left. The orange horizontal line marks the average return of 14.5% across those periods.

The most striking feature is that every bar is positive: the S&P 500 was higher one year after every midterm election shown. However, results varied considerably, from gains of roughly 2% to more than 30%.
Ultimately, the graph shows that election uncertainty has historically been followed by positive stock market performance over the subsequent year. Of course, past performance does not guarantee future results, but historical perspective provides an important framework to remind investors to remove emotion and political headlines from their decision-making process.

And then as the piece states in the close, “with the midterms less than a month away, it’s a good time to remind investors that fundamentals, not politics, have historically been the primary drivers of long-term market performance. The direction of interest rates, the strength of corporate earnings, and the durability of the AI capital expenditure cycle are likely to play a far greater role in shaping market returns over the coming year than the outcome of the midterm elections.” – NFM-25818AO (10/26)

It’s natural for investors to feel uneasy when the headlines get loud, but history reminds us that patience and discipline have been rewarded far more often than reacting to the news of the day.

Download Article Resource
Empire Advisory Group

We would ask that you review the attached piece at your convenience and please let us know if you have any questions or if you would like to discuss it further.  And as we always end this correspondence, please remember that regardless of current momentum and regardless of the key takeaways in this weekly perspective, we will continue to monitor and manage with a thoughtful approach based on your specific long-term objectives.

Thank you for your continued confidence and look forward to speaking soon.

john buss, financial advisor John P. Buss Financial Advisor
mike monoshefsky, financial advisor Mike Monashefsky Financial Advisor